Have you found the right Instagram influencers for your clients or company? Great! But that’s only a part of the influencer marketing puzzle.

If your company is like so many others these days, you may be wondering how to recruit social media influencers or key opinion leaders (KOLs) to help your brand’s cause or improve your influencer marketing.

After all, after finding an Instagram influencer to collaborate with, for example, the idea of pitching that person to help you market and in essence advertise your brand can easily feel intimidating.

So, how do you incentivize influencers to talk about your product or brand?

The following tips should help you shape your influencer marketing strategy whether you’re looking to work with the always popular micro-influencers or the currently trendy nano influencers.

Instagram Influencers: Tip 1

Don’t act like a cold caller on Instagram

Who likes to walk up to a stranger and immediately try to sell them something?

Cold calling isn’t one of the most effective strategies anymore. There’s a good reason for this: It’s all about making more pitches, all the time, and hoping you “hit” on something that will help you.

You’ll just annoy the person on the other end of the line with your “spray and pray” approach.

It’s the same thing with influencers: We’re super-busy and really don’t have time to hear about irrelevant products.

Remember that we’re probably not getting paid for our blog posts or Instagram stories. Chances are we’ll only work on stuff that interests us or our communities. Keep that in mind when deciding what to “pitch” us.

The more personalized your outreach is, the greater your chance of success.

(It also helps to have an Instagram marketing strategy, so you’ll know precisely what your goals are and how the influencer ties into one or more of them.)

instagram influencers

Work on building healthy relationships with Instagram influencers.

Instagram Influencers: Tip 2

Interact with your Instagram influencers on social media

Interacting with a target influencer on social allows that influencer to get to know you and your product. Doing so shows influencers that you know what they have to offer.

For example, you might find my posts on social media tools interesting because it allows you to “scope out” and audit the competition somehow.

Or you might be thinking about showing up for my next conference speech, like my presenting on influencer marketing at the recent Social Media Marketing World.

Either way, I have gotten to know what part of my work interests you.

Once you get to the place that you’re ready to ask the influencer to help, he or she will recognize your name, recognize your company, and already have a sense of what your audience might need to see.

But more importantly, you won’t be another random person who tries to “connect” with the influencer on LinkedIn, Instagram, or Twitter, and immediately pitch your idea.

Perhaps most importantly of all, you’re respecting the influencer’s valuable time by showing interest in them as an individual, as someone in business, and as someone whose opinions you respect and would be considered an asset to collaborate with.

control social media chaos with agorapulse

Instagram Influencers: Tip 3

Offer a freebie

Remember, for an influencer, time is valuable. For most of us, the blog or podcast, or even the Instagram stories aren’t what we’re getting paid for.

For example, I mostly get paid for my speaking and consulting. Certainly, there are content creators who get paid solely for their content sponsorships. But the majority of us exert our influence when we find something that’s valuable to us.

For instance, I wrote a long blog post on various Instagram marketing tools and included many ones I use regularly.

While quick entries for each product do help you sell more of your product or service, however, what really helps is when I continue to mention that item in multiple blog posts, podcast episodes, and even (virtual) presentations over the course of a year.

Continuing to mention something that I use, as a rule, means I need to have plenty of time to work with it.

For that reason, when I say give out freebies, I mean this needs to be something we influencers will use frequently.

Instead of giving us one product why not give us a few so that we can provide them to friends or members of our community for them to try out and see how they feel about your product?

Finally, the most important reason not to be stingy is that you’re being a friend to us.

These gestures of appreciation go a long way towards achieving your goal of getting the highly valued influencer nod.

offer instagram influencers a gift

Offer influencers a gift that they can use regularly.

Instagram Influencers: Tip 4

Follow up on your gift

You know how when you shop online a company might send an “abandoned cart” notice to your email? Or “retarget” you with banner ads that reflect your previous browsing of their website?

When I say “follow up on your gift,” I’m talking about an influencer-specific equivalent.

Depending on our area of influence, we get plenty of freebies: either in sheer numbers (for beauty products or corporate swag, for instance) or in the amount of time needed to work with them (software, marketing tools).

So, you want to make sure your freebie is one of the ones we open, use, and work with.

Following up and offering to help us with the product is a great way to make sure it gets some use. Not only that, but it’s good PR to build strong relationships with people who you hope will help you out.

Give us a good impression, and we’re more likely to work with you.

Instagram Influencers: Tip 5

Propose a long-term relationship

If you really want to show influencers how important their input is to your company, offer them a long-term interaction with your brand.

There are various ways of doing this.

For example, if you send an influencer a beta version of your software to test and then ask for feedback, you get an idea what they think before it even gets to the publication stage. More importantly, though, the influencer feels like they have a stake in how the product ultimately turns out, which gives them more motivation to pitch your stuff.

Another way is by engaging with them as a brand ambassador where you might work together over the course of a year-long contract with multiple activations.

Several other options exist, of course, and before entering into any of them you’ll want to make sure that the influencer represents your brand image well. This is the type of long-term influencer marketing that I recommend in my book The Age of Influence.

What We’re Learned About Instagram Influencers

Once you’ve recruited your influencer, take good care of them. If you work with a lot of influencers, you should have a formal program that gives them special access for their feedback. In other words, influencers shouldn’t have their ideas filed in the same bin as feedback from everyone else.

Furthermore, promote your influencer, for example, by advertising what they said about your product. Don’t just let the content (and influencer) stand out in the cold. Treat them well, and they’ll treat you well in a symbiotic relationship that’s mutually beneficial.

Best of all, long-term relationships often mean that influencers continue to talk about your products long after the initial influencer marketing campaign is over.

Remember, social media influencers are people just like you and me.


Get started on saving time and energy on your own social media management! Check out our free trial of Agorapulse to help you schedule, track, and measure all your social media efforts.

5 Common Sense Tips to Build Successful Relationships With Instagram Influencers